Nicotine alternatives have evolved significantly over the centuries, with snus and nicotine pouches offering distinct choices for users seeking alternatives to smoking. While both products serve a similar purpose, they have unique histories, compositions, and implications for health and regulation. Let’s delve into the differences, benefits, and potential concerns surrounding these two products.

What is Snus?

Snus is a tobacco-based product that has been around since the 16th century. Initially, it was made by grinding tobacco into a paste and allowing it to ferment for several weeks. Today, snus comes in various forms: some are contained in pouches, while others are loose tobacco.

Loose tobacco snus remains particularly popular in the southern United States, maintaining its historical significance. However, like other tobacco products, snus contains harmful substances, including carcinogens and heavy metals, which pose significant health risks.

What are Nicotine Pouches?

Nicotine pouches, such as Zyn, fall under the category of smokeless, tobacco-free nicotine products. Unlike snus, nicotine pouches do not contain tobacco. They were developed in 2000 by renowned Swedish doctor Karl Olov Fagerström, a leading researcher in nicotine addiction. Fagerström also created the Fagerström Test for Nicotine Dependence, which is still widely used to diagnose and rank nicotine addiction.

Dr. Fagerström intended nicotine pouches to serve as a tool for smoking cessation. He has highlighted their advantages over traditional snus and smoking, emphasizing the absence of dangerous substances like cadmium, ammonia, and lead. This makes nicotine pouches a safer option for smokers looking to reduce harm.

Are Nicotine Pouches Safe?

While nicotine pouches are not without risks, they present significantly lower health hazards compared to smoking or traditional snus. According to Dr. Vaughan Rees, a senior lecturer in Social and Behavioral Science at Harvard Public Health, products like Zyn offer a safer alternative for smokers unable to quit entirely. They lack the cancer-causing chemicals and toxic substances found in cigarette smoke, providing a harm-reduction option.

Effectiveness in Smoking Cessation

Nicotine pouches have proven effective for individuals seeking to quit smoking. One user shared their personal journey:

"I started using nicotine pouches to quit smoking after realizing the impact on my lung capacity, especially during fitness activities. While they were a great alternative and allowed me to improve my overall health, I eventually quit nicotine altogether, as I recognized the addictive nature of these products."

Although nicotine pouches eliminate many health risks associated with smoking, they still contain nicotine, which can perpetuate addiction. Users are encouraged to view them as a stepping stone to complete cessation.

Potential Appeal to Non-Smokers and Young People

Nicotine pouches are less appealing to young people compared to vaping. The sensation—such as the stinging gums experienced by first-time users—is less enticing than the flavored clouds produced by vaping devices. However, concerns remain about their growing popularity among young people.

For example, a 2023 survey in England revealed:

• 6% of young people aged 16-19 had tried nicotine pouches, up from 5% in 2022.
• By comparison, 20.5% of children aged 11-17 had tried vaping.

The modern branding and range of flavors available in nicotine pouches may still attract non-smokers and young adults. To mitigate this risk, educational efforts are essential to highlight the addictive nature of nicotine and discourage use among non-smokers.

Market Growth and Regulation

Since their introduction, nicotine pouches have experienced exponential growth. Companies typically implement strict measures to prevent sales to minors, such as requiring age verification on websites. However, concerns persist regarding their marketing and packaging, with some designs resembling candy, which could attract younger audiences.

Industry professionals and experts suggest balanced regulation. This includes:

• Stricter advertising controls and standardized packaging to prevent appeal to non-smokers and minors.
• Continued focus on harm reduction to support smokers seeking safer alternatives.

Conclusion

Snus and nicotine pouches cater to a similar audience but differ significantly in composition, history, and health implications. While nicotine pouches offer a safer alternative to traditional tobacco products, they are not without risks. For smokers looking to quit, these products can be an effective tool, but users should remain mindful of the potential for addiction. Educating the public, especially young people, about the risks of nicotine is crucial to ensure these products serve their intended purpose: reducing harm among current smokers without fostering new dependencies.

‍

[1] Zonnic: About Niconovum
[2] Fagerström Test for Nicotine Dependence
[3] HSE: Fagerström Test for Nicotine Dependence
[4] Zonnic: Nicotine Pouches Information
[5] Harvard Public Health: Zyn and Smoking Risks
[6] ASH Scotland: Nicotine Pouches and Snus Factsheet
[7] ASH UK: Vaping Among Young People in GB 2023

‍